God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything
by Christopher Hitchens
About halfway through reading Christopher Hitchens' new God Is Not Great it occurred to me that the book is ultimately kinda pointless. If I had to guess, I'd say the vast majority of the people who read it already realize that religion is bullshit, and I can't imagine very many people who aren't already of that point of view reading it and coming to that conclusion. That said, I'm always game for a good pile-on, and God Is Not Great is most certainly that.
The gist of Christopher Hitchens' argument against religion is that a) it's bullshit, in the sense that it's usually either invented out of whole cloth or "revealed" to someone who was probably just insane, b) it's no longer nearly as relevant, since we have modern science to explain, for example, what exists beyond the earth's atmosphere and why it rains when it does, and c) it's evil, in the sense that it's wreaked so much havoc on mankind throughout the ages and has been a general hindrance to the development of human understanding.
In three or four separate chapters, Hitchens goes to great lengths, with a barely disguised sense of glee, to describe just how full of shit the world's major religions really are. If you've spent any amount of time debating religion, my guess is that you're probably familiar with most of his major points. Basically, the Bible and the rest of these religious texts are full of shit that couldn't possibly happen, and if you actually take the time to research them, they're obviously just shit people made up and/or cribbed from various other religious text.
One thing I found especially interesting was a bit in the chapter on Islam in which he describes how it's arguably more bullshit than either Judaism or Christianity. Not that it matters one way or the other, but still. I realize it's anathema on the Internets to suggest that, given any two things, one could actually be better or worse than the other, but I think he makes a pretty good case for Islam being the worst of the world's major religions, which is a conclusion I arrived at a long time ago.
Similarly, if you've followed the news lately, I don't think I need to explain to you his argument for why religion is fucking up everything. Abroad, you've got crazed Arabs driving burning jeeps into airports. Meanwhile, back at home, you've got their crazed (though at least not particularly violent) counterparts building museums to explain to children how the world only came into existence 6,000 years ago, never mind the existence of dinosaur bones, which were obviously just placed here to test our faith.
Elsewhere in the book, he anticipates several arguments against his case against religion, and it's here where I think his argument goes a bit flimsy. For example, he tries to claim that while Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., an ordained Baptist minister, was our country's greatest civil rights leader, that doesn't really count because he wasn't a Christian, the reason being that he ran with a lot of godless communist types and was known to bang white bitches two at a time. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
Also, there's a bit where he claims that this country isn't nearly as Christian as you'd think, since people are naturally inclined to lie about their religious beliefs to fit in with the crowd, and since most surveys that ask people about their religious beliefs are skewed to make more people seem religious than there genuinely there are. I don't doubt that this is the case, but if it is, it would be cool if he'd conducted his own survey, to his own specifications, that really did show that this is the case.
For the most part though, I enjoyed the book, and I'd recommend it to anyone who's interested in the subject matter with the caveat that it's a bit more intellectually rigorous than it needs to be. It's not so much that it's hard to understand what he's talking about, but there's quite a few ultra-obscure literary references that you get the idea are only included to prove just how much smarter he is than everyone else. As if.
Recent Comments